A quick glance at the stack of books accumulating in my room will reveal my latest interest in the topic of human nature, which I must credit to a psychology course that I had the pleasure of taking last semester with a fantastic professor. The course, which very few of my friends and family members had heard of prior to my discussions with them about it, is called evolutionary psychology. In a nut shell, the discipline can be defined as the application of the principles of Darwinian evolution—natural selection shapes the evolution of organisms by "selecting" traits within them that enhance survival and increase their reproductive fitness—to the human mind. Put more succinctly, evolutionary psychology attempts to explain why particular psychological traits—such as memory, perception, and language—evolved and what, if any, adaptive problems they evolved to solve.
Evolutionary psychology is a relatively new discipline with its roots in a scientific field known as sociobiology, which studies social behaviour in animals in terms of adaptations produced by natural selection. Over the last 20 years or so, the discipline of Evolutionary psychology has been steadily expanding. Today, research on topics related to evolutionary psychology is published in a wide range of scholarly journals. Evolutionary psychology is considered to be a multi-disciplinary field because of its integration of research from several academic disciplines, such as ethology (the study of animal behaviour), evolutionary biology, social psychology, neuroscience, cognitive psychology, primatology (the study of primates), and behavioural economics, among others.
What was most appealing to me about the discipline was its candid, scientific approach to understanding and explaining human and animal behaviour, which I found to be very refreshing. After taking several social science courses, particularly ones in sociology, I was beginning to wonder whether it was possible to conduct research in modern-day academia WITHOUT being influenced by one’s political ideologies or those of the institution in which the research was being conducted. Evolutionary psychology, however, vindicated my doubts by demonstrating how behaviour could be understood in terms of the reproductive and survival benefits it conferred upon the organism. Different political ideologies notwithstanding, all evolutionary psychologists accept one basic theory which guides their research: the mind, like the body and its organs, was shaped by natural selection. Exactly how natural selection exerted its effects on the mind and for what reasons specific components of the mind evolved, however, is a topic of much debate among evolutionary psychologists and one that I find very intriguing.
The discipline of evolutionary psychology has so much to offer in terms of explaining and understanding human behaviour, particularly problematic ones on which there is a dearth of research such as violence and rape, yet so many intellectuals and laypeople dismiss its theories because of erroneous beliefs that it is a form of Social Darwinism or that its findings can be used to justify the status quo. These common misconceptions of the discipline, and the acrimonious responses they often elicit from critics, stem from two illogical arguments. The first is the belief that explaining a behaviour is tantamount to justifying it. And the second is the belief that if we even so much as hint that there might be a biological explanation for a behaviour that we are, in effect, implying that it is a "natural" occurrence and therefore we should simply accept it.
For example, when two scholars published a book in which they explored the possibility that rape may be adaptive trait in males the scientific community was outraged, to say the least, and denounced the book for what they perceived as a justification for rape. But if most scholars had actually read the book, from start to finish, or reviewed the research available on the topic, they would have realized that very few evolutionary psychologists, if any, believe that rape is an evolved adaptation or that there is a “rape gene”. On the contrary, most subscribe to the theory that rape is a by product of other male evolved psychological mechanisms, such as male’s desire for sexual variety, sexual over-perception bias (inferring sexual interest on behalf of a female when she isn’t interested), and use of violence to achieve goals. In the book, the authors argued that understanding the evolutionary roots of rape was necessary for developing effective interventions aimed at reducing the behaviour. The authors wrote the book because they were dissatisfied with the prevailing notion, popularized by feminists, that rape had nothing to do with sex, but was rather male’s attempt to overpower women. The latter theory had absolutely no empirical support whatsoever, but because it was postulated by feminists, most scholars chose not to question it scientifically, lest they be accused of being a sexist, much like the evolutionary psychologists who published the book were (even though they stated in the introduction of the book that they abhorred the crime and hoped to completely eradicate it).
As I will argue in this essay, the fears commonly associated with accepting evolutionary theories of human behaviour are not only unwarranted, but dangerous, for they restrict our vision of human nature and ultimately prevent us from better understanding its dynamics and, more importantly, how to improve it. As Steven Pinker pointed out in his book “The Blank Slate: The Modern Denial of Human Nature”, some of the greatest atrocities in human history have been committed by political regimes that denied the existence of human nature (e.g., Stalin in Russia). Before I address the main issue of the essay, however, a brief summary of the basic premises, research methodologies, and sample theories of the discipline are in line.
Evolved Psychological Mechanisms
The fundamental postulate of evolutionary psychology is that the mind consists of several evolved psychological mechanisms (hereafter referred to as EPMs), each of which was designed by natural selection to solve a specific adaptive problem routinely faced by our evolutionary ancestors. Some examples of EPMs in humans include language, mate selection, memory, and parental investment, among others.
Scientists have likened the mind as an information processor, much like a computer, that receives and processes input and produces output. This analogy, although very useful, has one major limitation, which is that a computer, unlike a human brain, is a general information processor that processes all information equally. The brain is divided up into separate, but not completely distinct, regions with specific functions that were, according to evolutionary psychology, shaped by natural selection to enhance an organism’s survival and fitness (i.e., the number of genetic offspring they produce). For example, the fusiform face area (FFA), which is located in the temporal lobe of the brain, is involved in processesing and recognizing faces, but it does not process olfactorial (smell) information. The visual cortex, which is located in the occipital lobe at the rear-most part of the brain, processes visual information. It does not, however, process information related to speech and language. Psychologists refer to the organization of the brain into various regions with specific functions as “localization of function”.
Setting aside its one limitation, the information processing analogy, also known as the computational theory of mind, provides scientists with a model to represent the complex processes involved in various cognitive functions such as thinking, feeling, and perceiving. According to evolutionary psychology, an EPM, such as the one for language, is designed to accomplish the following:
· Receive specific input from the environment, which in the case of language is words, syllables, sentences etc.
· Process and interpret environmental input according to an algorithm or a rule, such as an “if/then” statement. In the case of language, the algorithms governing its computations are the rules of language, known as syntax.
· Produce output in the form of a behaviour, a physiological response, an emotion, or information to other EPMs.
There are four features of an EPM:
1) Reliability- More often than not, the EPM solves the adaptive problem for which it evolved.
2) Efficiency- The EPM successfully solves the adaptive problem. In other words, the costs of the process are outweighed by the benefits it confers upon the organism.
3) Specificity- The EPM is designed to solve a specific adaptive problem and to process only a narrow slab of information.
4) Economic- The EPM solves the problem without expending exorbitant amounts of energy.
It’s important to note that an EPM is not a specific region in the brain, but rather a theoretical, abstract model that represents a complex cognitive process. Several regions of the brain are often involved in the functioning of an EPM. For example, a task as simple as finding something to eat involves the activation of several regions of the brain, such as the
· hypothalamus (which detects the homeostatic imbalance in the body, which we then perceive as hunger)
· The mesolimbic pathway, or the “reward circuit” in the brain, which includes the nucleus accumbens and ventral tegmental area (which release and respond to dopamine, motivating us to engage in the pleasurable act of eating), the limbic system (the amygdala for emotions associated with food; the hippocampus for memories of past locations where food was available; and the thalamus which screens incoming sensory information (vision, sound etc.) for stimuli related to food)
· Basal ganglia, which is involved in movement. A cluster of neurons in this brain region called the substantia nigra are disinhibited when the mesolimbic circuitry is activated, increasing bodily movement to so that the organism has a better chance of finding food in the environment
· Cerebral cortex which is involved in advanced information processing such as decision making and problem solving.
Research Methodologies
The scientific inquiry of evolutionary psychology relies not on one method, but rather a multitude of methods and sources of data that complement one another to either support or refute a hypothesis. Some of the methods employed by evolutionary scientists to conduct research include comparing different species, comparing males and females, comparing individuals within a species, comparing the same individual in different contexts, and conventional experimental methods, in which a control group is compared to an experimental group.
Evolutionary psychologists also utilize various sources of data for testing hypotheses, such as archaeological records, data from hunter-gather societies, observations, self-reports, life-history-data and public records, and human products.
Evolutionary Psychology Theories
Evolutionary theories can be divided into four broad classes of adaptive problems that humans recurrently faced in the ancestral environment. Within each of the classes below is an example of an evolutionary theory that offers an explanation as to how humans solve a specific adaptive problem.
1) Problems of survival and growth: satisfying the basic biological needs necessary for survival in order to be able to reproduce successfully.
The Embryo protection hypothesis: This theory proposes that sickness in pregnant women, known as “morning sickness”, is an evolved adaptation that prevents mothers from consuming certain foods that may contain teratogens, which are toxins capable of disrupting the normal development of the baby.
The evidence for this theory comes from the finding that the foods that pregnant women find distasteful correspond with the foods that have the highest level of teratogens, such as coffee, meat, alcohol, and vegetables. Moreover, it appears that pregnant mother’s aversion to these particular foods and beverages is strongest during the period when the baby is most vulnerable to toxins (roughly 2-4 weeks after conception when major organs are developing).
2) Problems of mating: finding, attracting, and retaining a desirable mate with whom one can reproduce offspring.
Parental Investment Theory: This theory makes two key predictions about the relative amount of investment each sex makes in raising offspring and its effects on mating:
1) The sex that makes the most investment in raising the offspring (which is typically, but not invariably, the female species), will be the choosiest or most discriminate in selecting a mate from the opposite sex.
2) The sex that makes the least investment in raising the offspring (which, again, is typically, but not invariably, the male species) will compete more with members of the same sex for access to the high-investing sex.
3) Problems of parenting: helping offspring survive and grow so that they themselves are capable of reproducing.
Paternity Uncertainty Hypothesis: This theory attempts to explain the universally observed discrepancy between the amount of parental care males and females provide to their offspring.
It postulates that males tend to invest less in raising offspring than females because of paternal uncertainty. By virtue of internal fertilization in humans, females are 100% certain of their biological contribution to their offspring. Males, on the other hand, can never be completely sure that they are the biological parent of their children, as there is some possibility that their spouse was inseminated by another man. Therefore, lest the children might not be their own, males typically invest less in raising children than females.
It is important to keep in mind that this is not a conscious process that men undergo when deciding how much to invest in raising their offspring. Males love their offspring just as much as their spouses do and are unique among primates in the amount of time and resources they devote to raising offspring. But relative to females, males generally invest less. Over the course of males’ evolution, natural selection has favoured genes that resulted in them investing less time and energy in a potentially evolutionary disadvantageous activity, i.e., raising another man’s children, and to invest more time and resources into activities that would increase their reproductive fitness, such as pursuing extra-marital affairs.
4) Problems of aiding genetic relatives- assisting your genetic relatives, who carry a certain percentage of your genes (depending on the degree of genetic relatedness), in surviving and reproducing offspring.
Hamilton’s Rule: The theory was developed to explain the conditions under which a gene for altruism could evolve and spread throughout a population.
Hamilton’s rule states that natural selection would favour mechanisms for altruism if the cost incurred by the individual was outweighed by the benefit conferred upon the recipient, multiplied by the probability that the recipient carried a copy of the same gene for altruism. Hamilton’s rule is represented in the equation below, in which “c” is the cost to the actor, “r” the degree of genetic relatedness between the actor and the recipient, and “b” the benefit to the recipient.
c < rb
Common Misconceptions of Evolutionary Psychology
Myth #1: Evolutionary Psychology is a form of “Social Darwinism”
Social Darwinism, which flourished in the early 20th century, posited that natural selection had produced within the human population a “social hierarchy”, in which the White Europeans race was at the top and thus biologically superior to the races below, such as the Black race. Evolutionary psychology is not a form of Social Darwinism. The latter is a gross misinterpretation of Darwin’s theory of natural selection, which measures an organism’s fitness or success in terms of how many offspring it produces, not by how much status, wealth, fame, or intelligence it has. [1]
Misconstruing evolutionary psychology as a form of social Darwinism leads one to believe that the theories postulated by the discipline are a justification for the status quo. This line of thinking has its roots in the enlightenment, during which time intellectuals began to criticize the notion of “race” and “gender” and the research that was being conducted to explicate the observed differences between these social groups. Admittedly, the science being produced at this time was, well, anything but scientific; in fact it was pseudoscientific. Social Darwinists and members of the Eugenics Movement were arbitrarily measuring the size of noses and head circumferences of the “inferior” races in hopes of discovering what made them so intellectually, morally, and socially inferior to the White European race. Although well intended, this “scientific” reasoning was based on the “Naturalistic fallacy”- the belief that things are the way they ought to be. Since Whites were much more successful than other races there had to be an explanation or a reason for this fact. Evading the minds of such scientists was the possible explanation that because these social groups were oppressed and denied equal rights and opportunity they were unable to become as successful as other social groups.
We know now that all races belong to the same species-the Homo sapiens-and that the notion of there being distinct races within the human population is, for the most part, a social construction. Sociologists, and other scientists who have made it their mandate to “debunk” the idea of race, frequently cite the scientific fact that all humans, regardless of the so called races to which we perceive them as belonging, are 99.96 percent genetically alike. Although true, this statistic, alone, does not dispute the reasoning that there may be biological differences between the races. Chimpanzees, one of our closest genetic relatives, share, roughly, 96% of our genes, and the differences between our and their species are substantial, suggesting that it is not the genome itself that accounts for the uniqueness of a species, but rather the unique way in which the genes are expressed. Moreover, scientists have already confirmed that there are certain biological differences between the races-skin colour, proneness to certain diseases and illnesses, metabolization of specific chemicals found in food and drink. So, theoretically speaking, because the races are NOT biologically indistinguishable, there could be differences between them in certain traits, be it physical or psychological. Currently, however, there is not enough concrete, empirical research supporting biological differences between races on psychological traits such as intelligence or violence.
Today, the pendulum has swung too far to the other side of the “Nature/Nurture” division. Science went from explaining differences between races and genders purely in terms of biology and genetics to explaining such differences purely in terms of the environment and culture. Indeed it has become fashionable to attribute all differences between genders, sexes, or people, in general, to “society”, the magical all mighty force that shapes all human behaviour, from teaching little boys and girls what is and what isn’t gender appropriate to instilling hostility and prejudice towards nonwhites in European populations. These claims often remain unchallenged by most modern-day scientists, who, lest they will be associated with Social Darwinists or the Eugenics Movement, eschew conducting research on the differences between races and sexes (or if they do decide to they are sure to err on the side of caution and pay lip service to “socialization” and “cultural” theories).
Unencumbered by political ideologies, Evolutionary psychology is one of the few disciplines willing and able to carry out research on these important, and indeed, controversial, topics in an objective, scientific manner. Evolutionary theories regarding gender differences attempt to explain such differences in the context of adaptations produced by natural selection. Scientists adopting this line of inquiry ask, “What adaptive problems did males and females routinely face and what EPMs did they evolve to solve them”. Certain gender differences, for example, are universal and cross cultural and have existed for as long as humans have documented history. They also are observed in non-state, hunter gather societies, where modern-day “society” (whatever the term entails today) exerts no influence on human behaviour. There are logical evolutionary explanations for these universally observed differences between the sexes that have been, and continue to be, confirmed in experimental settings. For example, it is considered an indisputable fact that males have had a greater propensity towards violence than females since our evolution in our ancestral environment, which is long before violent video games and UFC were introduced to our population. Because they were mostly hunters and had to compete with one another for access to the discriminate or “choosy” female sex, males developed EPMs sensitive to the contexts in which it was evolutionarily advantageous to use violence or aggression.
As can be expected, however, such research has landed the discipline in hot water. To say that the world of modern day academia, heavily grounded in left-wing Marxist ideologies, has been unreceptive to many theories postulated by evolutionary psychology is indeed an understatement. It is not uncommon to read articles or books written by scholars, particularly ones from the far left, i.e., radical feminists, in which vitriolic invectives are hurled at evolutionary psychologists for allegedly being bigoted, status-quo-supporting ignoramuses. So much for remaining critical and open to alternative explanations, huh?
Myth #2: Evolutionary Psychology is “deterministic” or “reductionistic”
Another common misconception of evolutionary psychology is that it is a form of "genetic
determinism" or "reductionism". Genetic determinism is a belief that all behaviour is determined or controlled by genetics. Very few scientists within the discipline espouse such deterministic views about human behaviour, but many are labelled as such by scholars sceptical of, and completely ignorant to (I might add) the theories of evolutionary psychology in general and neuroscience in particular.
Evolutionary psychology is grounded in the theory of natural selection, which operates at the gene level. That is, genes that predispose an organism to engage in a behaviour that increases its chances of survival and reproduction will be favoured by natural selection and spread throughout a population. It should come as no surprise, then, that evolutionary theories implicate genes into their explanations of EPMs. After all, what else but an organism’s genetic makeup, which was shaped by natural selection, can account for its innate behaviours? This is not to say that the environment bears no influence on behaviour. As I will argue below, however, human’s capacity to “take in” information from their surroundings, such as cultural norms or observation of others, is only possible because natural selection has endowed us with mental faculties capable of processing such information. Culture is not universal, but the underlying ability to understand and act accordingly to one’s cultural is. Knowledge is not universal either, but the ability to learn certain tasks is.
I suspect that critics who mistakenly believe that evolutionary psychology is a form of “genetic determinism” repudiate its theories because they perceive them as a direct attack of the notion of free will. This belief is based on the assumption that if a trait has biological origins, that is, that it can be explained by neurological activity in the brain, then we have no control over it and are thus doomed to mindlessly engage in it. However, this is faulty logic. It is true that the brain is responsible for all human behaviour, but this does not imply that we lack self-control or that free will is an illusion. Language is a behaviour with neurological origins, and yet we have control over what and when we speak. Behavioural theories which emphasize genetics and neuroscience are only inconceivable to those who accept the notion of dualism (that the mind is separate from the body) and thus believe that there is a “ghost in the machine” (i.e., a spirit) who controls our behaviour.
Evolutionary psychology has also been criticized for being a form of Reductionism, which is the contention that all behaviour can be explained in terms of—or “reduced” to—chemical and electrical events taking place in the neural tissue of the brain. This, too, however, is false. Understanding the anatomy of neurons and how they function is important, but it is not enough to adequately explain behaviour. Therefore, evolutionary psychologists utilize abstract cognitive models to comprehend the mental faculties that are involved in a behaviours functioning. Moreover, as was mentioned previously, evolutionary psychology draws from not one field of research but several, integrating into its theories findings from cognitive psychology, social psychology, behavioural economics, artificial intelligence, primatology, ethology, neuroscience, and evolutionary biology.
Myth # 3: Evolutionary Psychology Neglects the Importance of the Environment
Despite accusations made by armchair critics of the discipline, Evolutionary psychology does not disregard the importance of the environment in determining behaviour. On the contrary, many of its theories acknowledge the reciprocal interaction between genes and the environment in producing behaviour. An EPM is shaped by our genetics but its operation is influenced by environmental input. Acknowledging the importance of genes does not negate the importance of the environment, and vice versa.
For example, male’s mating preferences are influenced by environmental factors such as availability of food. In areas where food is relatively scarce, males prefer women with a larger waist-to-hip-ratio because such a figure indicates that the woman is healthy—i.e., has access to food—and thus capable of conceiving a child. In many developed areas today, however, such as North America where food is abundance, the size of a woman’s figure is not necessarily an honest cue to her health and fertility. Therefore, in these areas men generally prefer women with smaller waist-to-hip-ratios. Women’s mating preferences are subject to environmental input as well. If a female grows up in a household with a stable relationship (i.e., two parents), this is a cue to her that long-term relationships are safe and thus should be pursued. As a result, she will likely forgo early sex, experience menarche later, and enter a long-term relationship as a young adult. Females who grow up without a Father in the home, however, will perceive this as evidence that long-term relationships are not safe or stable, and will therefore likely pursue short term relationships, experience menarche and engage in sexual activities at an earlier age than females who grew up with a father present in the home. Both of these examples illustrate that an EPM is not capable of producing output without receiving and processing environmental input.
I was once debating with a person on an online forum about the topic of evolutionary psychology, specifically the limitations of its theories, and she kept insisting that the discipline places too much emphasis on genes and not enough on the environment. After about three postings or so, it occurred to me that we were offering two very different, but not contradictory, explanations for the same behaviour. Evolved psychological mechanisms, such as the one for language, are designed to receive and process specific environmental input, such as words and syllables. How the environment interacts with these EPMs to produce output (e.g., language) is a proximate explanation of the behaviour, i.e., how it works. Why a particular behaviour exists, i.e., what function(s) does it serve, is an ultimate explanation. I think it’s important that people understand the difference between these two behavioural explanations
Myth # 4: Evolutionary Theories Argue that Humans are Innately Evil and Selfish
Humans take care of their children and aid relatives in moments of despair because they love them. People engage in sex because they find it pleasurable and enjoy pleasing their partners. Friends help each other because they care deeply for one another and value their friendships. Spouses love one another. Humans are capable of solving disputes without resorting to violence. People from all races and ethnicities can get along with each other. Women can be successful in a competitive job market and men can be nurturing toward their children. People volunteer their time to non-profit organizations and make charitable donations. Adoptive parents love their children as much as biological parents. Some couples can, and do, remain monogamous.
These are universal facts that evolutionary psychology, contrary to what many believe, does not dispute. Natural selection operates and exerts its selection pressure at the gene level, not the individual or group level. As Richard Dawkins described in his influential book, “The Selfish Gene”, genes, not people, are selfish. Contraception, suicide, adoption, pornography, and vasectomies are all examples of humans choosing not to behave in the interest of their genes. Evolutionary theories do not disregard free will or self-control. They merely argue that these agencies that dictate our behaviour do not exist outside of the mind, but rather operate and function deep within the neural tissue of the cerebral cortex and were shaped by natural selection to make decisions that would, on average, increase our survival and reproductive success, thus propagating the genes responsible for their functioning throughout the population. Parents invest time and resources into their children not because they share half of their genes, but because they LOVE them. Similarly, we help our genetic relatives not because they too share our genes, but because we LOVE them as well. We engage in sex not because it spreads our genes, but because we enjoy it. Natural selection has endowed us with these strong emotions to encourage us to engage in the behaviours that evoke them because doing so enabled our evolutionary ancestors to survive and reproduce in greater numbers.
Conclusion
In his charmingly witty and erudite book, "The Blank Slate: The Modern Denial of Human Nature", Steven Pinker offers readers an insightful examination as to why so many intellectuals and laypeople, from both sides of the political spectrum, are hostile towards the idea of a universal human nature. He then assures the readers that they need not fear that acknowledging the existence of a "human nature" would result in discrimination, inequality, determinism, or nihilism. On the contrary, Pinker argues that such knowledge about the evolutionary underpinnings of human behaviour can be used to develop better social policies and interventions aimed at reducing problematic behaviours, such as violence and racism.
I think that the premise of Pinker’s book—that we deny a human nature because we fear its implications—summarizes the points I have discussed in the present essay. Beneath the political and moral veil of ignorance in which we cloak ourselves when faced with the daunting question, What is human nature?, is an inquisitive scientist who is perplexed but also intrigued by the essence of organisms, the internal force that makes species unique from one another. When applied to animals, the theory of evolution makes perfect sense to human beings and we accept its anatomical and behavioural explanations without any reservations or moral objections. Even when evolution is used to explain the functioning of the human internal organs—i.e., why the heart pumps blood, why we have an immune system—we are not adverse or hostile to its theories.
But when the same theory is applied to the evolution of the human mind, we object with vehemence, flouting any scientific attempt to explain human behaviour in terms of natural selection. Why so many continue to inexorably believe that the human mind, the “pilot” or “commander” of all behaviour, is exempt from the laws of natural selection is beyond me. The goal of this essay, however, was to dispel any myths associated with the discipline of evolutionary psychology that may be deterring people from subscribing to its theories and to clarify its premises, purposes, and objectives. If by writing this essay I have accomplished one of these feats I will be satisfied.
[1] In response to a careless act committed by another person, I’ve often heard people comment that “you’d think natural selection would have weaned these idiots out”. Ironically, such statements reveal the person’s own level of ignorance and lack of understanding of the theory of evolution via natural selection
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteBrilliant Justin!
ReplyDeleteI don't agree with all of your conclusions but they are well thought out... and argued!
Take a bow!